[FnB]

Claude kicks ass, he would obviously rule!

[Bulletproofboy]

Tommy owns Vice City. He has a huge Gang.

Claude is hated by everyone. He just has Maria behind him.

[Desert Fox]

Tommy has a big mouth but cant back it. Claude doesnt say a word but shows up with the muscle.

[Samil]

I vote for Fido.He's the Silent Assassin and I agree with Desert Fox.

[shot n the ass]

tommy will kick Claude ass

[Big Z]

I think Tommy will win,cause he is not hated by the hole city like Fido

[Chief]

Claude. Tommy is a cheap rip-off of scarface. Alls they did was change his name and make him look different, I know it was a Reference towards him but it was just to much. Also the last mission was to easy, Just wait around the corner and throw a grenade down the stairs ( Like 4-5)
And Sonny is dead, In GTA III you had to go to her mansion, Kill the guards and chase after her heli, Go to the dam and kill all her guard than shoot down her heli and go to maria...Who btw is guarded by a hidden guy who almost killed me when i first beat the game. Plus tommy talks to much, while they are fighting tommy would prolly be talking a shitload while claude emptys 20 shotgun shells into his back all stealth like.

[Deji]

Claude

[Sтεαм.]

You guys just bumped a month old topic.

[Scott.]

TOMMY .

He will kick everyones butt!

[Someonesinyourhouse]

Kind of tommy in a way, but claude would be the type to go unnoticed, claude has no mercy but revenge in heart, tommys more of a reasonable dude

[Ultraussie]

Excuse the bump.

Tommy would win, Claude isnt as good at hand to hand combat, and he punches so soft he cant even dint cars!!! So while Claude Speed "speedily runs to his pink manana and drives off like a wus", Tommy will outrun the car, kick the door off, throw him out, and kick his ass into space, only to land back down again in the water.

[Lenny]

In a one on one, Claude's fighting technique was a little better then Tommy's, notably the age would make a serious outcome of the battle, if they battled in lets say '95 or '92 when Claude(Fido, Nameless guy what ever) would age around 25 (i think), Tommy would be around 30-40.
I say Claude

But with gangs, i would say Tommy since he haw power, and Claude is just a one man army...

[VCKilltimer!_!]

Aside from all if or if not talk, weather or not Tommy would have more guns, and backup from various gangs. I still think if it was purely those two going at it, I'd still think Tommy would beat the crap out of him.

[Bulletproofboy]

If they were both in the same time period.. Tommy..

Vice City was in 1986, Claude was like a little kid then.

Tommy would kick Claude's ass.

but in 2001, Tommy would be a 50 year old man with no gang, and Claude would pwn him then.